Ring vs Nest Doorbell: Which Smart Doorbell Wins?
Ring and Nest are the two heavyweights of the smart doorbell world, and picking between them mostly comes down to which ecosystem you're already in. Got a house full of Alexa devices? Ring is the obvious play. All-in on Google Home? Nest makes way more sense. But there's more to it than just ecosystem. Ring offers more models at more price points. The 2nd Gen Wired is a fantastic budget option — it's only about $60 and gives you 1080p video, motion detection, and two-way talk. The Doorbell 4 and Battery Doorbell Plus step things up with head-to-toe video and Pre-Roll previews so you can see what happened before motion was detected. That Pre-Roll feature is a big deal because most doorbells only start recording after they detect movement. Google's Nest Doorbell is more of a one-size-fits-all approach. Fewer models, but the hardware is solid and on-device processing means it can tell the difference between a person, a package, an animal, and a vehicle without needing a subscription for basic alerts. Ring charges for that through Ring Protect. And that subscription cost adds up over time, so factor it in.
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best For | Key Pros | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ring Video Doorbell (2nd Gen) Wired | Doorbell | Affordable video doorbell | Buy on Amazon |
| Ring Video Doorbell 4 (Battery) | Doorbell | Pre-Roll video captures | Buy on Amazon |
| Ring Battery Doorbell Plus with Head-to-Toe Video | Doorbell | Head-to-toe 150x150 degree field of view captures packages at ground level | Buy on Amazon |
| Google Nest Cam (Indoor, Wired) | Camera | On-device person detection | Buy on Amazon |
| Ring Indoor Cam (2nd Gen) | Camera | Very affordable | Buy on Amazon |
| Wyze Cam v3 Indoor/Outdoor Security Camera | Camera | Incredibly affordable | Buy on Amazon |
Detailed Look at Each Product
Ring Video Doorbell (2nd Gen) Wired
1080p HD video doorbell with two-way audio and night vision. Motion detection with customizable zones. Real-time notifications. Works with Alexa for announcements and live view on Echo Show. Hardwired installation for continuous power.
- Affordable video doorbell
- Easy Alexa integration
- Customizable motion zones
- 1080p video quality
- Requires Ring subscription for video history
- Wired installation only
Ring Video Doorbell 4 (Battery)
1080p HD video doorbell with color Pre-Roll captures four seconds before motion triggers. Quick Reply lets you send pre-recorded messages when you cannot answer in real time. Removable rechargeable battery eliminates the need for doorbell wiring.
- Pre-Roll video captures
- No wiring needed
- Quick Reply messages
- Night vision
- Ring Protect subscription for video history
- Battery needs recharging every few months
Ring Battery Doorbell Plus with Head-to-Toe Video
Ring's Battery Doorbell Plus captures a tall, head-to-toe field of view so you can see packages on the ground and visitors' faces in the same frame. The improved battery life and quick-release mount make installation and maintenance straightforward without any wiring.
- Head-to-toe 150x150 degree field of view captures packages at ground level
- Quick-release battery pack charges in about 4 hours
- Works with Alexa for announcements on Echo devices
- Ring Protect subscription required for video history
- Wi-Fi signal strength is critical for consistent performance
Google Nest Cam (Indoor, Wired)
Indoor security camera with 1080p HDR video and night vision. On-device processing recognizes people, animals, and vehicles. Three hours of free event video history. Works with Google Home and Alexa.
- On-device person detection
- HDR video quality
- Free event video storage
- Works with Google Home and Alexa
- Wired only (no battery option)
- Full history requires Nest Aware subscription
Ring Indoor Cam (2nd Gen)
Compact indoor security camera with 1080p HD video, color night vision, and two-way audio. Manual privacy cover for physical camera blocking. Works with Alexa for voice-activated live view on Echo Show devices.
- Very affordable
- Manual privacy cover
- Color night vision
- Alexa integration
- Ring subscription for video history
- No pan or tilt
Wyze Cam v3 Indoor/Outdoor Security Camera
Budget 1080p security camera with color night vision using a Starlight sensor. IP65 weather resistant for indoor or outdoor use. Two-way audio, motion detection zones, and free cloud storage for 12-second events.
- Incredibly affordable
- Color night vision
- Indoor and outdoor rated
- Free 12-second event clips
- Full-length recording requires subscription
- Occasional connectivity drops
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Ring and Nest doorbells require a subscription?
Both work without one, but you lose a lot. Ring Protect ($4/month) unlocks video history and person detection. Nest Aware ($8/month) adds 30-day video history and familiar face detection. The difference is Nest gives you basic smart alerts (person, package, vehicle) for free. Ring doesn't — without a sub, you just get generic motion alerts.
Which has better video quality?
The Ring Battery Doorbell Plus shoots in 1536x1536 with a head-to-toe field of view — it's excellent for seeing packages on the ground. Nest Doorbell does 960x1280 with HDR. Both look good in practice. Ring's wider field of view is the real advantage here.
Can I install a smart doorbell myself?
Absolutely. Battery-powered models like the Ring Doorbell 4 just mount with screws — no wiring at all. Wired models connect to your existing doorbell wiring, which is still pretty easy if you follow the instructions. Most people finish in under 30 minutes.
Do smart doorbells work with Apple HomeKit?
Not great, honestly. Neither Ring nor Nest officially supports HomeKit. If you're deep in the Apple ecosystem, your best bet is a HomeKit-compatible doorbell from Logitech or Aqara, or use a workaround like Homebridge. It's doable but not plug-and-play.